Veterans and Military Families

Fighting Dems Stand Up Against "Vicious Right Wing Smears"

Posted by on August 3, 2006 at 10:57 AM

The newest target of a swift boat attack? Rep. John Murtha, who is being sued for speaking out against some of the worst atrocities in Iraq.

As Glen Greenwald writes:

The lawsuit filed yesterday against Murtha based on his comments about the shootings of 24 civilians at Haditha is frivolous for multiple reasons. But worse than its legal inanities is the fact that its goal is so clearly to punish Murtha not for any supposed defamation, but because he is a prominent and effective political critic of the administration and of the war. He must therefore be smeared and punished, and that is clearly what this lawsuit is intended to accomplish.

The most damning fact about the motives behind lawsuit is that it is Rep. Murtha -- and only Rep. Murtha -- who is being sued for the alleged defamation, despite the fact that countless other public figures, including a sitting Republican Congressman, Bush loyalist Rep. John Kline, voiced similar and even more extreme accusations about the Marines in Haditha. And yet none of them has been named in this lawsuit. That's because, plainly, this lawsuit is about punishing Murtha for his political views and attempting to deter anyone from publicly criticizing the war and the Bush administration.

Well it's not going to be that easy to tarnish John Murtha. He is fighting back and so are his brothers-in-arms. Former U.S. Senator Max Cleland, who was himself the target of vicious Republican attacks in 2002, will travel to Pennsylvania during the next two days to defend U.S. Rep. John Murtha.

"I am not going to let vicious right wing smears against a good man go unanswered. I am honored to support my fellow Vietnam veteran as he runs for his 17th term in Congress," Cleland said. "I am outraged at elements of the Republican Party who still believe that defaming an opponent''s character is the best way to disagree with him. I am tired of men who never fought in combat, accusing men who bear the scars of war, of acting unpatriotically just because they disagree with our president. This type of politics is un-American and needs to stop."

From the Tribune-Democrat:

Rendell said the anti-Murtha faction will meet opposition at today’s press conference.

“Boy, are they in for a surprise,” he said. “If they attack Jack Murtha, they are going to be attacked back.”

Dozens of veterans groups from the region are planning to attend.

Terry Menear, from the Somerset Vietnam Veterans Association, will be there.

“I think they ought to stay where they belong,” he said. “I am all for John Murtha.”

Murtha said critics are trying to take attention away from his mission to redeploy troops away from Iraq.

“I try not to be distracted from my mission, which is to change the direction of our country,” he said.

“It’s great to see so many people support me in my district.”

Dot Helsel, a resident of Stonycreek Township, supports Murtha and believes most residents in Johnstown still do.

“I think he’s done an outstanding job for the Johnstown region,” she said. “You don’t always agree with somebody, but I would say most people in this area like him.”

Helsel said she does not think protesters or negative attention will affect Murtha’s campaign.

“He’s been there too long now,” she said. “You can disagree with somebody but you don’t have to be disagreeable.”

Mary Miller of Johnstown, national president for the Association of Vietnam Veterans of America, said Murtha protesters have taken his words out of context.

“A lot of these people who are outing him have never served in the military and they don’t understand what it’s like,” said Miller, whose group is a service organization for the Vietnam Veterans of America. “It’s just upsetting, really. He’s always been for the veterans and the families. He’s done a lot.”

This isn't the first time Rep. Murtha has come under fire for his views on the war. It isn't the first time fellow soldiers have come forward to defend him, and it won't be the last.

Comments (9) «

God Bless and keep John Murtha. What a good and brave man.

1
freeforall on August 3, 2006 at 03:51 PM

Where have all the Morals gone from the GOP? They have lost their edge. What a great fall it was! I could just cry.

2
freeforall on August 3, 2006 at 04:03 PM

The best way to stop this in the bud is go after the Republican incumbents who can be linked to receiving funds from these same scumbags. Just the threat of another Republican corruption scandal could be enough to sink those in close races.

Let's get out the gumshoes and legal attack hounds and begin trolling. We have three months to dreg up the names of those who are associated - even distantly - with this fraud. If they accepted funds from the same people funding this suit, they are just as responsible; and we should charge them with it.

In fact, it might be smart to just assume that the top Republican leadership are involved and follow them around on the campaign trail asking questions about their association wherever they stop. Just the hint of doubt about a possible scandal could make things hot enough for them to call off these rabid wolves. After all, all of them are already under investigation for the lialation of some law.

The Republican incumbents already have high gasoline/home energy prices, the Iraqi quagmire that could last another decade, the promise of a resurgence of Bush's unpopular Social Security "Reform", fears of another Katrina FEMA debacle, outsourcing/illegal hiring, domestic spying, Medicare doughnut hole, and the stem cell research issue to carry around as excess baggage.

Add to that another bogus smear scandal (and the threat of a visit by Bush to their state right before the election) and you have the recipe for disaster for all vulnerable Republican incumbents.

If they can turn up the heat, so can we. And there is no John Kerry/DLC political strategists who can hold us back this time. Those that aren't moving are dead in the water this election. Let's make them swim till they drown in their own lies.

3
SandyH on August 3, 2006 at 05:17 PM

Nobody has done more for the military than John Murtha.

NOBODY

Fight back this time, please.

4
fade2bluz on August 3, 2006 at 08:59 PM

I have faith in John Murtha that he can handle himself and this attack. And we must have faith in the electorate that they can, by now, recognize a transparency when they see one. I believe we can credit the current administration with this new ability of the electorate to see things for what they are instead of how the administration wants us to see them. We could call it the Bush Legacy.

I always thought it was odd with the Swift Boat guys that they charged that Kerry was lying about the way he got his metals (I think that's right, if I recall correctly) but they originally verified Kerry's account. Then they later charged Kerry with lying, but they themselves lied either at the beginning, or during the swift boat political charge. You can't trust them. If they accuse someone of something, it's a sure bet that they themselves are guilty of the charge.

5
Rally on August 4, 2006 at 02:41 PM

Well it's not going to be that easy to tarnish John Murtha. He is fighting back and so are his brothers-in-arms. Former U.S. Senator Max Cleland, who was himself the target of vicious Republican attacks in 2002, will travel to Pennsylvania during the next two days to defend U.S. Rep. John Murtha.

Sure it is. Y'all obviously bypass the garbage heaped on Kerry by the No-Fly-Boy mendacity brigade. Where was Murtha during the ShortBoat bullshit?

6
caliban on August 5, 2006 at 09:56 PM

Oh, yeah. Semper fi.

7
caliban on August 5, 2006 at 09:57 PM

Is it me or did everyone miss the quote about "murder in cold blood" How quickly you forget the traditions of innocence when you have a political agenda. If they are guilty, then they are to be punished. I am sure you would want the presumption of innocence for you son.

8
excalibor on August 10, 2006 at 01:47 PM

It takes real courage to stand up to King George.

9
pee-wee on August 11, 2006 at 07:03 PM


« Hide Comments

Comments are now closed for this entry.