Post from Tonya Jones's Blog:
Black vs. Blue, When it's About the Green?
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.
In the Democratic race for the presidency the latest media hype pits African Americans against the so-called white blue collar voters. We hear the constant discussions of tantrums and threats of some groups of Democratic voters, threatening to vote for the opposing party if their candidate doesn't become the nominee. Some question if the party's divisions created by the long protracted primary will be beyond repair in the general election.

In this corner, you have the loyal 90% plus voting block of the Democratic Party, the African Americans. There has been unfair criticism of the black community's overwhelming vote for the first viable candidate that most represents them. At the outset, the pundits wondered why African Americans were so slow to support Obama.The initial black community apprehension of Obama was due to a lack of trust that the country was ready to elect an African American, Obama was not as well know as his opponents, and above all else African Americans had to believe he was viable. Understanding the urgency of change in the white house, African Americans were more skeptical then most. The same complaints weren't waged when the "black vote" helped nominate and elect Bill Clinton and many other sometimes mediocre white men. But now somehow this dependable voting block is supposed to forego or not have pride in an accomplished, articulate, inspirational visionary candidate like Obama.



We have in the next corner the "average Joe" or white blue collar voter. While the African American vote has not been respected and been taken for granted, the white blue collar voter has been blatantly exploited. The politicians all dance and prance in their best portrayal of blue collar garb and compete on who represents the "regular guy". Some candidates wink and suggest that the other candidate will change life as you know it; lacking respect for "average Joe's way of life. This is the source of the whole Obama elitist controversy. Obama was correct in his analysis that the fear of losing guns, and the exploitation of religious issues has been effective political tactics causing this sector to vote against their own economic interest.

Some suggest that African Americans have bestowed blind allegiance to the Democratic Party. I propose the black community votes as all voters should, on the strength of the parties' platform and policies promoting prosperity for them. Even when the Republican's message is cloaked in "compassionate conservatism", the majority of African Americans aren't impressed by the party of "Voodoo" or "trickle down" economics. Those on the bottom and middle of the economic scale, in this current economy are being schooled on the differences in the results of the political philosophy and strategy of each party.

The politics of "mass deception" attempt to convey Obama as an elitist to one of the very groups that nurtured and gave him life, his white blue collar grandparents. Obama maybe the first president that is one step removed from the average Americans concerns, a man of the people. Obama chose to sacrifice the big salary and be an advocate for unprivileged people after law school. His family just paid student loans and purchased their first home after his bestselling book. Both blue collar voters and black voters must not partake in the promotion of the black vs. blue, when the divisive tactics are always about the "green". Spite all the tantrums and threats, there should be no doubt of a united Democratic Party against the Republican philosophy that brought us record fuel prices, enormous job loses, recession, the Iraq war, the record deficit, and no solutions on healthcare.

Reader Comments
  
Heck-of-a-post
By WRM May 7th 2008 at 1:02 pm EDT
Thanks
  
loyal 90% plus voting block of the Democrats
By Nelsd May 7th 2008 at 1:05 pm EDT
I wish that was true
Re: loyal 90% plus voting block of the Democrats
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 5:31 pm EDT
At least 90% of African Americans vote Democratic.
Re: loyal 90% plus voting block of the Democrats
By Blueberry May 9th 2008 at 12:00 pm EDT
whether the Democratic nominee happens to be Black or White.
  
Mindless Sheep
By Sharkhunter May 7th 2008 at 1:14 pm EDT
You know that's how many are characterizing us Tonya? Some still say Black voters need to be 'sacrificed'. Boy. What a blunder on their part.

But I got another one. We know Black people get undercounted. And we have perhaps a majority of Black folks who are not even registered to vote. Many of those who are registered remain disillusioned.

So thanks for bringing this home because its in-line with what I have been trying to stress today.

Its not about Black Power but Green Power and Obama just is rolling in more dough while Clinton campain is struggling and in-debt.


If blue-collar America is duped into voting for McCain all I ask is they dont blame Obama. You get what you vote for. Republicans will just send this country into further downward economic spiral and escalate the Iraq war and perhaos expand operations into Iran and Afghanistan.
Deleted by Mike
Re: Mindless Sheep
By Woman at Large May 8th 2008 at 10:10 pm EDT
She loaned the money to her campaign.
  
The white male "blue collar"
By Private Joker May 7th 2008 at 1:29 pm EDT
Democrats have struggled gaining this vote since the 1960's. If you ever canvassed these neighborhoods, you'd get a better sense as to why. It's hard to reconcile a group people who work hard for very little with a group that argue for exclusive affirmative action priveleges for themselves.

Supporting universal programs to alleviate poverty and job stress would bring these groups together. Obama and Clinton had an opportunity to promote REAL universal health care and decided against it in order to conform with corporate interest.

There is a solution, but unfortunately the campaigns failed us again.
Re: The white male "blue collar"
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 5:46 pm EDT
I have canvassed these areas, and they had no problems with my message because it was delivered with kindness and respect.
Re: The white male "blue collar"
By Private Joker May 7th 2008 at 7:19 pm EDT
They wont vote for someone who associates with people like Reverend Wright and Farrakhan. It's common sense. Blacks wouldn't vote for a white person who associates with white racists.
Re: The white male "blue collar"
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 10:18 pm EDT
Haven't you beat that dead horse!

Wright's views don't equal Obama's views. As the Pope doesn't equal all Catholic's viewpoints. I guess the public won't vote for a Catholic candidate because of any association with the priest scandal in their church.

Wright =racist+ Wright=Obama+ Obama =racist
The public knows this doesn't added up!

Again you would have to believe, Obama hates the white mother that gave him life.

Guess what, America has voted for Obama elevating him to become the nominee!
Re: The white male "blue collar"
By Woman at Large May 8th 2008 at 10:09 pm EDT
Tonya, the problem I see here is that it's been exposed that not everyone who's voted for Sen. Obama is Democrat. In other words, Republicans have switched their party affiliations for the primaries in order to nominate the man they most want their candidate to face in November - a man they believe McCain can beat. So I don't trust the numbers. What I want from Obama is answers. What's your plan for solving the problems that face us, other than "change?" Why do you support the likes of Farrakhan? Is your denunciation of Wright genuine, or as he says political? Finally, WHY WON'T YOU SALUTE OUR FLAG? If you answer the way you've been answering so far, that you're identifying with "your people" and their complaints against America, then you're telling me that your agenda is to change the government of my country so it makes "your people" more comfortable, never mind at whose expense. I won't say that's racist. I will say that you shouldn't expect the majority of Americans to buy your platform in November.
  
I am one of the Caucasian voters
By Mike Barack Hussein May 7th 2008 at 4:36 pm EDT
over age 60 who supports Barack Obama.

I don't care what color he is; but I do care about his passion, intelligence, and integrity.
Re: I am one of the Caucasian voters
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 5:35 pm EDT
I'm proud that you and I are on the right side of history!
Re: I am one of the Caucasian voters
By marsha May 7th 2008 at 7:22 pm EDT
Me too, Me too.
I'm pink right now... forgot the sunscreen.
He will win.
Peace is coming!!!!!!!!!!
marsha
Deleted by Mike
  
If Obama wins
By Mark in LA May 7th 2008 at 5:19 pm EDT
and I think he will win the nomination, he will be in an excellent position to win the Presidency.
If he wins the Presidency, and carries through with his campaign agenda, then we'll see blue-collar whites and blacks profiting from a progressive White House and Congress, and the ties should be cemented into an unbeatable coalition for years to come.
There's no place for pessimists in a hard-fought Presidential Campaign.
We can do this, and we will.
Re: If Obama wins
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 5:41 pm EDT
Have you noticed that Obama, you and the majority of Obama supporters speak in terms of we? It is always I, I, I will...with Hillary. It's just a difference in leadership style.
Re: If Obama wins
By marsha May 7th 2008 at 7:27 pm EDT
WE........... isn't it great..... WE........
It will take us all. Knocking on doors, wearing buttons, talking and showing our support of him so others follow.
We are at our best when we are united and support each other.
I'm locking arms with ya....
Can you feel it?
Peace is coming!!!!!
marsha
Deleted by Mike
  
Re: If Obama wins
By FeministBoomer May 7th 2008 at 7:40 pm EDT
You said it all, there.........Gas is 3.65 here!!!I do believe it is going to $4.00+ by the end of summer........

We are headed for a Depression, and people are concerned about what someone SAID about this country....I'M CONCERENED ABOUT WHAT OUR LEADERS ARE DOING TO THIS COUNTRY, AND MORE IMPORTANTLY, THE UN-AMERICAN POLICIES THEY ARE IMPLEMENTING ON THE AMERICAN PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!
Re: If Obama wins
By Donia19 May 7th 2008 at 9:12 pm EDT
They are thinking about rationing rice...gimme a break?
  
so true
By Democrat in Ellsworth, ME May 7th 2008 at 7:01 pm EDT
this is old race politics, right out of the 1960's playbook from the south
  
Barack Obama is an inspiration
By Mike in Raleigh May 7th 2008 at 7:03 pm EDT
regardless of color, creed, religion, or even universe. He is truly an inspiration and exactly the catalyst we need to seize back our country and our civil liberties.

I'm a 58 year old, Italian-American male and am working like hell to help get Barack Obama into office. On to West Virginia now (Link )!
Re: Barack Obama is an inspiration
By marsha May 7th 2008 at 7:31 pm EDT
I would vote for him if he were purple and believed in a doorknob. It's about leadership, vision and truth.
peace is coming!!!!!!!!
marsha
Re: Barack Obama is an inspiration
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 10:42 pm EDT
Marsha,

WE believe and together WE can achieved!
  
excellent post
By Mark (and I'm not sure about the former) May 7th 2008 at 7:08 pm EDT
I don't think the policy, if your black vote for barack passes the acid test. I know a lot of black people see obama as their great hope...I also know that a lot of white people see Obama as their great hope. So maybe people really see Barack as their best chance for a change.
I don't agree with everything he says but that does not mean I don't want to listen to him.
  
some day people will wake up
By Liz May 7th 2008 at 7:21 pm EDT
Some day, maybe, people will awaken and realize that it is not about black and white. It is about class, about righ and poor. No one likes to say that. We are supposed to be a democracy, a classless society.

One of the most effective tools used by the upper 10% control the majority is racial and cultural polarization. So far they have done a good job since the beginning of our country's history.

I am taking heart from this campaign however. I see signs that people are getting smarter. One of the indications I saw was that they didn't fall for the gas tax fake gift. A lot of pundits today are saying that they think that hurt Clinton in Indiana quite a lot.
Re: some day people will wake up
By Mike in Raleigh May 7th 2008 at 9:37 pm EDT
lol, and her answer today when asked was more of the same...she still thinks people will believe her gas tax transfer to the oil companies' profits is good for them. Hope she keeps aligning with McCain, the contrast will be crystal clear(er).
  
How can you say?
By Private Joker May 7th 2008 at 7:32 pm EDT
I'm sick of these "white people are racist" narratives. The white blue collar vote has been neglected and that's why so many vote Republican.

How can you say that Democrats take the black vote for granted? Affirmative action is a blatant attempt to pander to these people. When blacks complain, they get their way almost all the time. The complaints are checked later for veracity and questions are asked later. People fear blacks and everyone is afraid to criticize them because if you say the wrong thing, God forbid, you will be pegged a racist. Criticize white people and they give you a Ph.D. It's impossible to be a white male and register a complaint about obvious double-standards and not be considered a racist. It's Orwellian thought control.

Obama will get plenty of white votes, but he needs to distance himself as much as possible from his past. I'm not sure if he can pull that off.White people, especially those who aren't in priveleged positions are very cautious about Obama. I see a lot of those votes going to McCain.

If Obama's the candidate, fine by me...

but damn, we really ought to run Hillary.
Re: How can you say?
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 10:32 pm EDT
I'm sorry that the drug companies haven't produced a pill for ignorance, because folks like you need a cure for that poison that pours from you. When Obama is President, maybe we can make the anti-poisonous propaganda pills free for ya!

I pray for you instigator.
Re: How can you say?
By andy492 May 7th 2008 at 11:50 pm EDT
I have to agree with you......it's not always about qualification, experience or even who you surround yourself with in the way of advisors. Sometimes for some people it's all about perception....plain and simple......yes white people will support Obama just as black voters do support Hillary Clinton however here's the litmus test: Anybody that thinks the Republican party is not going to mobilize against Barak Obama if he's the nominee is just plain out of touch. The Rebublicans have way more money in their base and the fact is that there are more white people in the United States that there are African Americans. If just 15% of Hillary's supporters swing to McCain, Obama will be just another Senator who's looking for a new church! People will say lots of things when they are in public but the voting booth is private and NO ONE knows who they are voting for. McCain will beat Obama and we can thank the Obama supporters for that.
Re: How can you say?
By Woman at Large May 8th 2008 at 10:19 pm EDT
Andy, it's in Sen. Obama's power to stem that 15% defection. All he has to do is list a few real ideas he has about solving America's problems; explain why he supports and apologizes for the likes of the racists Farrakhan and Wright; describe to us what his real relationship with those shady characters Rezko et al is; and finally, Salute our Flag!
Until then, it's Hillary or McCain.
  
I agree
By Sue Sue's Straight Talk Express May 7th 2008 at 7:54 pm EDT
Isn't it funny how people are so gullible. I am amazed at how many have painted Obama as out of touch. What are they talking about?

Moreover, the media and the pundits are turning us all into racists. They are stirring the pot and labeling us all.

You know what I find interesting, white working class men did not want to accept blacks in baseball, football or basketball. Now look. They will accept us on the playing field but they won't accept us in the White House.

I believe it is the media who is painting people as racist and people are buying into it. I heard a commentator say, "Rev. Wright is scarring the white people". What kind of mess is that? How could white people be scarred by the comments of a narcisitic preacher?
Re: I agree
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 10:38 pm EDT
I'm sick of the word racist being irresponsibly used. Good people can have some conscious or unconscious prejudice without be racist.
Deleted by Mike
Re: I agree
By Tonya May 8th 2008 at 8:30 am EDT
That old fear of the black man stealing your women is funny because the black man appears to be in popular demand. They seem to be like the latest handbag everyone has to have one! LOL Made that is the secret plan to win the war on discrimination, just populate the earth with brown & black babies! LOL

This ignorance tactis was used in ads to weaken Harold Ford, but you can use that against Obama.
Re: I agree
By Tonya May 8th 2008 at 8:44 am EDT
I need to get more sleep.

I meant the tactics of exploiting those old stereotypical fears are over!
  
Red, White, Purple, Polka-Dot, Whatever Color The Voter Might Be...
By BatonRougeDem May 7th 2008 at 10:55 pm EDT
Obama is still not experienced to be president, leader of the free world, or the party's standard bearer.

And deny it or not, black voters has had an impact in this primary.
Re: Red, White, Purple, Polka-Dot, Whatever Color The Voter Might Be...
By Tonya May 7th 2008 at 11:07 pm EDT
If this election was based on experience McCain would win against both our candidates, but it is about CHANGE.
Re: Red, White, Purple, Polka-Dot, Whatever Color The Voter Might Be...
By Teon Cromwell Jun 8th 2008 at 9:24 pm EDT
yes we need change because without it were doom on the path were on