Post from What About Us?:
This One Is A Must Read!!!
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.
More Bang for the Buck: Harvard Costs Less than Prison!!!

Among the many social issues debated around water coolers, across Internet forums, and in the presidential race, whether or not the United States government has an obligation to educate its masses isn't much of a priority, but government spending (and what it does or does not accomplish) is a hot topic.

A report issued by The Pew Center On The States details the prison population count for all 50 states and the cost of that population's upkeep. Of the more than 300 million residents of the United States, over 2.3 million of its adults are in prison or jail. That's one out of every 100 of us.

This is a greater number of people than the combined populations of Washington, D.C., Milwaukee, Wisconsin, Denver, Colorado, and Seattle, Washington. The United States' prison population exceeds that of any other country in the world - including China, a country with over 1.3 billion residents.

In 2007, the states spent over $44 billion on the incarcerated. After adjusting for 2007 dollars, that's a tin cup-rattling 127 percent increase since 1987. Currently, this works out to almost $19,000 per prisoner per year.

For the same period, the adjusted spending on higher education climbed 21 percent. Due to recent overhauls in financial aid, the United States could send their entire criminal population to Harvard for a four-year degree and still spend less money per prisoner per year. For those currently making less than $180,000 a year, the cost of a Harvard education is $18,000 per person per year.

With this in mind, one wonders how the states justify cuts in education that would benefit the free citizen: those who have yet to (or would never) embark on a career of crime. For less money, we could be graduating rocket scientists instead of paroling rocks.

Sure, there are your serial killers, sex-offenders, and other assorted repeat offenders who should, by all means, stay in prison forever, but are there 2.3 million of them? More than one million of those currently behind bars are non-violent offenders. What, then, could possibly be the justification for there being that many people in prison in the first place when it costs less to educate them before they so much as pick a pocket? Vocational training and state universities, after all, cost a fraction of a Harvard education.

Alas, education is not a constitutional right - at least not on the free side of the wall. Part of the cost of prisoner upkeep includes their healthcare, vocational training, and higher education. We could say those who aren't smart enough to avoid a life of crime will only take advantage of educational opportunities when its readily available and free - and we'd be right. The same could easily be said for the rest of us. Why, then, aren't we providing education and healthcare as a preventative (for crime, poverty, and unemployment) instead of using it as a treatment?

That's not how the United States taxpayer prefers to do business. Numbers and votes don't lie: the United States taxpayer prefers to provide its criminal population with the very amenities it refuses to provide its law-abiding population. Also, the lawful have to do their own cooking.

Between the number of Americans without access to education and healthcare, and the number of people in prison, one could say American taxpayers are now too sick, too ignorant, and too tied up to take care of themselves.

No wonder the government wants to maintain the status quo.

********************************************************
I wish that I could take credit for this one because the words are very close to what I would have said myself, but it was written by Diana Hartman (a freelance writer, mother of three, and a (Ret.) US Marine spouse from Wichita, Kansas)

Also, if you find yourself feeling passionate about this human rights issue, you can join in on the fight by visiting famm.org, a wonderful organization dedicated to fighting against the injustice of mandatory-minimum sentencing...

Reader Comments
  
Re: Simply Speaking
By Fogotten Citizen Mar 8th 2008 at 12:55 am EST
I agree that if you do the crime you should do the time, but across the board all crime should not equal to the same punishment. It shocks me sometimes when people suggest that all crimes are equal and even more when people have this idea that all people begin life at the same starting line. Some people are born impoverished, under some of the most heinous conditions that you can imagine. Others are just taught different survival methods from growing up in the ghettos and having to do whatever is necessary to survive and eat from an early age. It is shocking to me to see the lack of understanding and compassion in this country. Please remember that most African-American males in this country find it more of a reality to end up in prison than on a college campus, and for the most part they are right. You cannot convince me that you could not change this momentum with proper education. I agree whole-heartedly with the post that I submitted because I have been hopeless and it is because I received a decent education that I regained my hope and began to see how important it was for me to pass a little bit of this hope along.

And I'm forced to think of the play Les Miserable! I attended a performance of it not too long ago and I remember the audience feeling sorry that Jean Valjean got such a long, hard sentence for stealing a loaf of bread to feed his family. Maybe it is easier for American people to feel sorry for the white Jean Valjean but much harder for them to relate to the everyday black version doing the very same......
  
let's send
By Julie Mar 8th 2008 at 12:33 am EST
all the convicts to the Ivy League, and send all the Harvard students to prison, where they can put their superior IQs to good use by devising a better system for socializing people at the same dollar cost ^o^
Once they come up with the plan, they can leave...heh...not until.
Meanwhile the cons can graduate with valuable degrees and get jobs on Wall Street, where they will no doubt feel most at home :P
well, except for the ones who wind up with Pharm. degrees...lol...or LAW!
  
Re: Simply Speaking
By Fogotten Citizen Mar 8th 2008 at 2:04 am EST
I appreciate your response because you are right. There are plenty of successful African-Americans in this country, you are speaking to one! But being that I grew up in not so great surroundings, I can assure you that the "majority" of African-Americans have not been so lucky as to beat the odds. We applaud all those that made it through the cracks, but most of us never forget that we are the lucky ones. I have seen first hand the racial discriminations in this country, the racial profiling, the overcrowded classrooms with no heat or air conditioning, the empty refrigerators, the borrowing of electricity from the neighbors next door...I could go on and on about what I have seen. These are the conditions in which I personally grew up in. And this was normal for us and quite typical. Not everyone slips through the cracks of it. And do me a favor, ask your "AA" friends about the conditions of which they came, and ask them how many people they know that are still living in them. It is not easy to always do the right thing when you are faced with so much adversity. Personally, I am one of the many that did not start off doing the right thing. In my attempt to run from those conditions (and many more that I have not mentioned here) I did several things that I am not proud of to survive. The miraculous thing is that someone saw something more in me and helped me to see the very same. It is because of the compassion bestowed upon me that I was able to turn my life around and I will not stop believing that if I bless someone else with the same compassion that they may be able to see that there is hope for change in their lives as well. You can go on believing that prison is what is necessary to "teach" people a "lesson". But I can tell you first hand that prison only begets anger, waste and further dysfunction. Education on the other hand begets confidence, growth and understanding. Which would you rather have walking the streets next to you at night?
  
And...
By SemperFiWM Mar 8th 2008 at 1:52 am EST
why don't we bring back tar and feathering, stocks, or just caneing?

By the way, I loved that Mom who made her child stand in front of the school with the apology sign for acting up. Responsibility is key.